As we navigate the complex landscape of the automotive industry, a pressing question arises: Does larger size correlate with better overall performance for corporations? At first glance, one might assume that bigger companies, due to their extensive resources and market presence, would naturally excel in every aspectHowever, looking at the contrasting fortunes of different players, it's clear that size alone is not a reliable metric for success.

The case of Contemporary Amperex Technology Co., Limited (CATL) illustrates the archetype of a company that rises to the pinnacle of its sectorRenowned for its advanced battery technology, CATL commands a commanding lead with an astonishing revenue of 400.9 billion yuan in 2023, far surpassing its closest rivals, such as Samsung SDI and LG Energy SolutionWith a remarkable 40% share in both the power and energy storage battery markets, CATL’s dominance is undeniable.

In stark contrast, we have Huayu Automotive Systems Company Limited—a giant in its own right, boasting total assets of 176.1 billion yuan and liabilities of 114.5 billion yuan as of 2023, yet its performance showcases a very different narrative

With revenues of 168.6 billion yuan, Huayu bests several market participants combined, but a closer examination of net profit reveals a concerning realityFor example, the combined net profits of Fuyao Glass Industry Group and Desay SV Automotive closely parallel Huayu's own, despite the latter’s larger scale.

Furthermore, Huayu’s profitability metrics appear less than stellarIts Return on Equity (ROE) measured at 13.03% in 2023 significantly lags behind that of competitors like Berthelot and Top GroupAn interesting trend emerges from the data; while Desay SV's ROE escalated to 21.94% by 2023—a considerable increase since 2020—Huayu’s growth has stagnated, indicating underlying issues in its profit-generating capabilities.

Why does this discrepancy in performance exist? The variables at play include product potential and industry focus

• US Debt vs. China’s Reserves: A Race to Depletion?
• Did you make money in the A-shares in 2024?
• How to Handle a Market Crash
• What’s Causing Volatility in Asian Markets?
• AI Progress: Models No Longer the Bottleneck

Many companies showcase strong growth qualities across performance, valuation, and profitability metrics, which often correlate with their innovation and adaptability.

In a simplified framework, let’s categorize the market landscape along two axes: vertical for product growth potential and horizontal for industry concentrationCompanies positioned toward the upper right quadrant thrive, showcasing strong growth potential while remaining competitive in an increasingly consolidating market.

To illustrate this further, consider these five segments of the automotive parts market, each paired with respective companies:

1. **High Value with Promising Growth**: Desay SV, specializing in advanced cockpit and driving control technologies, finds itself in this advantageous segment
2. **Platform Suppliers**: Companies like Top Group are resilient, manufacturing lightweight components and innovative thermal management solutions that cater to the burgeoning electric vehicle sector

3. **High Technical Demand**: Berthelot excels in line control products, which require extensive technology investment, placing them firmly in the high-demand segment
4. **Market Leaders Despite Slower Growth**: Huayu Automotive, as a major player in exterior and interior vehicle components, maintains unparalleled market share, but faces challenges within stagnant growth environments
5. **Stable Yet Limiting Growth**: Joyson Electronics, while capturing the passive safety niche, also contends with reduced growth prospects in an industry that is becoming increasingly concentrated.

In comparison, companies with high-value products and robust growth characteristics are experiencing rapid revenue and profit surges, while Huayu Automotive's performance reflects a hesitance to evolve in pace with industry trendsParticularly alarming is Huayu’s situation where increased earnings do not equate to improved profit margins

Data reveals that between 2017 and 2023, their income surged from 140.4 billion to 168.6 billion yuan, yet net profits diminished from 9.1 billion to 8.09 billion yuan.

The first three quarters of 2024 further underscore these troubling trends, with Huayu noting a revenue decline of 1.7% and a net profit plunge of 5.63%. This stagnation raises critical questions concerning its strategic approaches.

To stimulate growth, Huayu Automotive could pursue a dual strategy: enhancing the individual vehicle value and increasing sales volumeImproving vehicle value could stem from expanding business lines, enhancing product technology, or creating high-value-added componentsAlternatively, boosting sales volume might involve diversifying their customer base or focusing on high-demand models—a strategy successfully employed by companies like Huguang Technology and Huayang Group, which thrived by aligning with the expansion of Huawei's product line.

Now, does this strategy seem effective for Huayu? Unfortunately, the reality suggests a mixed picture

Their attempts to diversify product lines and penetrate new markets remain limitedAlthough the company ambitiously branches into areas like electric mobility and smart technologies—developments that naturally align with global trends—current revenue streams heavily rely on traditional products such as exterior components that generate over 71.8% of total revenueThis dependence on increasingly commoditized segments presents a challenge for sustainable growth.

Prospects appear bleaker when we consider the sluggish market growth of external automotive components—projected to rise at a mere 3% annually until 2026, pushing the industry towards saturation.

Additional concerns surface with diminishing sales from major clientsIt’s pivotal to note that over half of Huayu’s revenue originates from SAIC Motor Corporation

As SAIC’s sales decline, attributed to competitive pressures particularly from new energy vehicles, the implications for Huayu cannot be ignoredLatest reports indicate that in 2024, SAIC's projected sales of 4.013 million units fall short when juxtaposed against the rise of competitors like BYD, which expects sales of 4.27 million units.

However, there is a silver lining as Huayu gradually shifts its focus to new clients, including Tesla, Seres, and BYDThe company's new orders in the first half of 2024 indicate a significant pivot towards electric vehicle components, with over 70% of new contracts catering to these innovative models.

In conclusion, while Huayu Automotive's stature and current market presence are unquestionable, its growth trajectory paints a different pictureThe company needs to address the challenges of slowing revenue growth and profit margins